Brendon Kay, QB, Cincinnati

UDFA. Was signed by the Steelers as a UDFA but released in August. With such great size, you would expect him to throw with more authority. He has enough talent, though, to stick on a roster for some time as a developmental prospect. But it will have to be for another team than the Steelers.

All-Star Games: NFLPA Collegiate Bowl.

Positives: Above-average height. Good bulk. Ran a pro-style system in college, so should be more prepared for a pro offense. Has adequate arm strength. Throws with nice touch. On the run, he shows above-average anticipation and adequate accuracy. Is fairly poised under pressure, and stands in to deliver the pass under pressure. Is a tough runner with above-average speed who will dive for extra yards. Has a good sense of when to take off running and when to pass. Good track speed, ability to change directions, and generally above-average lower-body explosiveness for the size and position.

Negatives: Below-average hand size. Has a fairly long injury history. Knee injury in 2009 made him miss most of season. Missed all of 2010. Had shoulder, back, ankle, and rib injuries in 2012. A sore shoulder in Summer 2013 caused him to miss the early part of the 2013 season. He consistently locks onto receivers and tends to only read one side of the field. Below-average red zone decisions. Throws with Below-average accuracy on crossing routes and at most levels of the field. Below-average velocity, and his deep passes tend to die. Underthrows deep receivers consistently. He seems overly careful with the ball, hesitating consistently and holding it too long – resulting in sacks. He checks down a lot and seldom throws the ball more than 20 yards in the air. He doesn’t move around very well in the pocket, and doesn’t sense the rush well, either.

Projection: No need to draft him in fantasy.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Dustin Vaughan, QB, West Texas A&M: Division 2

Cowboys, UDFA.

All-Star Games: NFLPA Collegiate Bowl.

Positives: Great height and bulk for the position. Seems poised inside the pocket. Shows generally adequate accuracy, anticipation and decisiveness. Can vary his velocity fairly well, with adequate velocity on short and medium passes and nice touch on deep passes. On the run, he keeps his eyes downfield and throws with above-average accuracy. Will go through progressions at times – especially in the red zone. When given time in the pocket, he shows good throwing mechanics. Good vision and balance as a runner, and isn’t easy to bring down. though his track speed is below average for the position, it is adequate for his size. Adequate quickness for his size.

Negatives: below-average track speed. BBelow-average hand size. He ran a spread offense in college, and may not be ready to run a pro-style NFL offense. Below-average arm strength. His medium and deep throws are generally inaccurate, and he will throw low or high often. He will pass up – or just not see – open deep receivers in favor of shorter patterns. Though he can go through progressions at times, he pretty consistently locks into receivers. Has a long windup. Seems slow to get set up in the pocket, probably as a result of running a spread offense where he was just expected to get the snap and throw it immediately.

Projection: Far down the depth chart, he looks like practice squad material. May be viewed by some as a developmental 3rd quarterback. No need to pay attention to him in fantasy football or in the draft, but will probably be on some roster at least for the short term.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Kenny Guiton, QB, Ohio State

Bills, Tryout. Most of his positives come from his running ability, but he does have some passing ability, too. He should at least get into a camp, and possibly end up on a practice squad. Needs a lot of development time, and I don’t expect him to consistently succeed in the NFL or be a factor in fantasy football, but should get a spot as a 3rd quarterback on some team, and get a lot of scout team reps.

All-Star Games: NFLPA Collegiate Bowl.

Positives: Adequate height and hand size. Is able to throw fairly accurately with touch – especially on fade routes. He also shows above-average velocity and an ability to fit the ball through tight windows. Knows when to throw the ball away. Good play fakes. As a runner, he shows above-average power and good speed. He is also patient as a runner and follows his blocks well. Was also the holder on field goals. Adequate overall lower-body explosivesss and track speed at pro day workout.

Negatives: Below-average bulk. Generally below-average accuracy at all levels and will underthrow deep routes. He shows consistently late recognition and late delivery. Locks onto his receivers. Below-average throwing mechanics and has a long, three-quarter delivery.

Projection: No need to draft.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Caleb Herring, QB, Nevada-Las Vegas

All-Star Games: NFLPA Collegiate Bowl.

Positives: Above-average height. Adequate hand size. Is versatile, and also played wide receiver in 2012 and was also the holder on field goals in college. When flushed out of the pocket, he keeps his eyes downfield and shows adequate accuracy on the run.

Negatives: Below-average bulk – more of a wide receiver build. Lost the starting quarterback job in 2012 to a freshman, and didn’t start again until early 2013. Ran a spread offense in college, and may not be ready for a more pro-style NFL offense. Below-average accuracy on short and medium passes and, even in short spaces, he will throw the ball behind receivers. Makes a lot of decisions before the snap, and eyeballs his receivers consistently. Below-average velocity. He tends to hold the ball too long. On the run, he will often throw across his body and not set his feet, losing velocity and giving defensive backs a jump on the ball. Mechanically, he is inconsistent. He has a fairly long delivery with a release point that drops down to sidearm at times, adding to his inaccuracy. He consistently throws off his back foot. Under pressure, his throwing motion tightens up and it becomes more about his arm than about his whole body. Below-average speed and acceleration, and doesn’t look like a natural runner. Seems to run out of control and will often slip making cuts. Inside the pocket, he is not very elusive and doesn’t seem to realize where defenders are coming from.

Projection: UDFA. Because of his versatility, I expect him to at least get into a camp. I don’t expect him to make a team – at least right away. His best bet might be the CFL. No need to draft in fantasy.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Sean Schroeder, QB, Hawaii

Former transfer from Duke.

All-Star Games: NFLPA Collegiate Bowl.

Positives: He is a generally accurate thrower with nice touch within 20 yards. Above-average accuracy on short routes. Throws with very nice touch on passes to the flat and his short and medium passes are very catchable. On his dropback, he holds the ball at the ready, which allows for a quick release. He sets up quickly in the pocket. As a runner, he shows average speed, but is willing to run when necessary. Gives extra effort on runs to get the first down.

Negatives: Slighty below-average height and bulk for the position – built more like a wide receiver. Below-average arm strength and velocity. He has to put way too much air under passes to get them deep, and his intermediate passes will die after about 20 yards. Generally poor accuracy on routes past 30 yards. On the run and outside of the pocket, his accuracy suffers. He also looks inexperienced at throwing deep, and doesn’t read the deep safety well. In the red zone, he appears indecisive, and will hesitate to throw.

Projection: UDFA. In some systems, such as a West Coast system, he may be an adequate backup. He will likely never start in the NFL, though, barring some transformation such as Graham Harrell and Chase Daniel saw in the past 5 years with a patient quarterback coach and some weight room work.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

James Franklin, QB, Missouri

UDFA. Signed as a UDFA by the Lions in May but was released in August. He certainly has the talent to play in the NFL, at least as a backup. I think a lot of his problems will be fixed with a good quarterback coach and some consistent teaching. It would also help if he doesn’t get hurt again. He has the athleticism to thrive in a lot of offenses. Mostly, he reminds me of Dennis Dixon, the former quarterback at Oregon.

All-Star Games: NFLPA Collegiate Bowl and South Carolina All-Star Bowl.

Positives: Above-average bulk. Above-average hand size. Above-average arm strength and adequate velocity. He moves very well inside the pocket, and will step up or slide laterally to find passing lanes. Nice touch and accuracy on crossing routes and deep passes. Generally adequate accuracy on intermediate routes. Is a better passer on the run and outside of the pocket. Nice high release point. Keeps shoulders squared and eyes downfield when flushed from the pocket. Doesn’t seem to panic under pressure and can get the pass away at the last second. Knows when to throw the ball away. Is a very good running quarterback. Shows above-average vision for cutbacks and has the speed and quickness to take advantage of it. He knows when to slide as a runner to protect his body. Runs tough in short yardage and goal-line situations.

Negatives: Slightly below-average height. Comes out of a spread system, and may not be ready to run a pro-style NFL offense. He seemed to look lost at times in NFLPA game practices, which makes me question whether he has a long learning curve ahead of him in the pros. He shows inconsistent accuracy overall, including on touch passes, and throws it consistently high. His mechanics need a lot of work, partially because he has had to change his throwing motion so many times due to injury. Though he has a nice release point, it comes with the cost of a long delivery. That, combined with his bad habit of locking onto his receivers, gives defensive backs a jump on the ball. He often throws off his back foot under no pressure, losing a lot of velocity as a result. He also needs work on his footwork during his drawback. His accuracy and velocity seemed less at the end of 2013, which may be a result of his shoulder injury. Has a somewhat long list of injuries. Injured shoulder in Spring 2012 and injured knee in early October 2012, missing a month. Separated shoulder in October 2013 and missed a month.

Projection: No need to draft, but don’t forget about him – keep an eye on him to see where he lands.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Ryan Montague, RB, Louisiana College, Division 3

Seahawks, UDFA.

All-Star Games: Dream Bowl, one of the third-tier all-star games – generally for Division 3 and NAIA seniors.

Positives: Runs with good body lean and shows good power, usually finishing runs very strong. Breaks a lot of arm tackles and knows how to use a stiffarm. Above-average cutback vision, and has the above-average quickness and ability to change directions to take advantage of that vision. Adequate speed and burst. Okay hands. Generally looked strong against Division III competition.

Negatives: Below-average ball security.

Projection: He’s not someone to draft in fantasy, but he may be someone to keep an eye on.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | 3 Comments

Tyler Tettleton, QB, Ohio University

Son of former MLB player Mickey Tettleton.

All-Star Games: Medal of Honor Bowl — one of the lower-tier all-star games.

Positives: Has adequate arm strength, though not great. On the run, he keeps his eyes downfield to look for open receivers and doesn’t always just tuck the ball and run. He is also more accurate on the run than in the pocket. Shows OK accuracy and touch on deep passes. As a runner, shows good speed and pretty good vision in the open field and is willing to dive for extra yards. Has experience running a high-tempo offense and making quick decisions. Is OK at using play fakes.

Negatives: Slightly below-average size. On crossing routes, he shows below-average accuracy. Not effective at reading defenses and will lock in on receivers — throwing passes directly to defenders. Ran a pistol spread offense in college, so may not be ready for a typical NFL pro-style offense. 3/4 release. Suspect decisions on the run and throws across his body to defenders consistently. He sometimes has too much faith in his mobility and will hold the ball too long when he needs to just throw the ball away.

Projection: Round 7-UDFA. In the right system — one that takes advantage of his mobility — he could eventually be developed into a solid backup. But he will need to work on reading defenses and decision making. Overall, I see him as a practice squad player who could contribute at some time down the road. No need to draft him in fantasy.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Chris McGinnis-Parker, RB, Eastern Oregon: NAIA

Small for the position.

All-Star Games: National Bowl, a game where you would expect a handful of players to get rookie camp tryouts, but not real NFL contributors.

Positives: Shows above-average speed and quickness and changes directions quickly. Hard for defenders to get a hand on him. Good ability to stop momentum and get back up to speed immediately. Is decisive behind the line and shows good enough vision and lateral motion to hit cutback lanes. Very good balance after contact. Pretty effective as an outside runner. Is a willing pass blocker, and is adequate at times.

Negatives: Lacks strength, and is easy to bring down once a defender gets a hand on him. Not a very successful inside runner. Below-average ball security technique, and holds the ball too low through the line. Though he works at it, he’s just not strong enough to be a pass blocker in 3rd-down situations.

Projection: UDFA. I don’t expect him to make it in the NFL, but he reminds me most of Trindon Holliday, who has been a pretty successful return specialist and bit player in the NFL despite his super-small size. But the combination of small size, low level of competition and lack of name recognition probably mean the best he can hope for is a rookie camp tryout. Probably best served in another league.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Joe Clancy, QB, Merrimack College: Division 2

Adequate size.

All-Star Games: National Bowl and Medal of Honor Bowl. Both are low-level all-star games of the type where you’d expect a handful of players a year to get a tryout or UDFA contract with an NFL team.

Positives: Above-average accuracy on routes toward the sidelines. Shows nice touch on short passes and generally throws a catchable pass. Shows enough arm strength, though not very impressive. Can vary his release point to fit the ball through traffic at the line. Under pressure, he generally shows adequate accuracy and poise and can find the open man under duress. Has some experience under center. Has adequate speed and is willing to run. When he’s on the move, he is able to set his feet to deliver passes.

Negatives: Though his short passes have enough touch, they aren’t consistently accurate. His throwing mechanics are erratic, and he throws off his back foot at times for no reason. He shows below-average anticipation skills — throwing to receivers before they break their routes, and not with enough touch to give them time to react. Though he sets his feet to throw passes on the run, passes from outside the pocket are not very accurate. He also makes below-average decisions outside of the pocket and will throw it into heavy coverage. Overall, he eyeballs receivers often and doesn’t read coverages well, letting defenders easily converge on his passes. Below average quickness as a runner.

Projection: UDFA. He might show up as a camp arm or get a tryout in an NFL camp, but there’s no need to draft him.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment