Brock Jensen, QB, North Dakota State: FCS Division

UDFA. Signed by Dolphins as UDFA but released in August. Has enough athleticism, poise, experience, and passing ability to find a spot in the NFL as a backup. The comparably lower level of competition in the FCS means he may have more of a learning curve ahead of him, and is best viewed as a long-term development QB.

All-Star Games: Invited to South Carolina College All-Star Bowl, but declined for unknown reason.

Positives: Adequate height and good bulk for the position. Above-average hand size. Above-average track speed and vertical leap for the position. Has experience running a pro-style offense, so he should be more ready for an NFL offense. Throws with above-average arm strength and touch. Fair accuracy on medium and deep routes. Improved his deep passing accuracy and touch over his college career. Steps up in the pocket under pressure and shows a little bit of escapability. Agile enough to sidestep pass rushers. Is willing to run, and sacrifices his body for extra yards. Runs with above-average speed and adequate quickness. Strong enough runner on short-yardage situations. Follows his blockers well as a runner.

Negatives: Below-average accuracy on the move and on timing routes. Inconsistent progressions and tends to eyeball targets. Misses wide-open reads down the middle. Forces passes into coverage often. Below-average velocity. Below-average throwing mechanics – throws off back foot without pressure. Under pressure, tends to just throw the ball up for grabs. Doesn’t sense the rush up the middle. Takes too many chances in the red zone and needs to learn to throw the ball away. Throws a little bit of a wobbly pass.

Projection: He is not someone to pay attention to in fantasy football, but he could help an NFL team as a developmental prospect.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Nathan Scheelhaase, QB, Illinois

Positives: Throws with adequate arm strength and velocity. Adequate accuracy on short passes. Above-average accuracy on rollouts, and he keeps his eyes downfield on the run. Decision making improved by his senior season. Nice play fakes. Runs with above-average speed and quickness. Is a strong runner with good mobility inside and outside of the pocket. Good peripheral vision and sets up blockers well in open field.

Negatives: Not as strong of a passer as a runner. Below-average accuracy on medium and deep routes. Tends to lock onto receivers and not go through his progressions. He tends to panic when rush comes at him up the middle. At times, he throws off of his back foot for no reason. Is indecisive and holds the ball too long at times. Runs a little off balance, and can be knocked off his feet fairly easily after contact.

Projection: UDFA. At best, he’s a long-term development project, but the improvement he showed over his college career may point to a higher-than-expected ceiling. Not worth drafting in dynasty rookie drafts.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Adam Muema, RB, San Diego State

Was a junior. Before the Combine incidents and the subsequent fallout, I had Muema as my top RB – going in Round 2. To me, he was the best back in the draft, but I was definitely in the minority on that opinion. Now, of course, I’d be surprised if anyone even signed him to a UDFA contract. Has the skills to be one of the few all-purpose backs in the league, though he will definitely have to work on blocking and ball-security technique. But, as of May 2014, he’s reportedly seeking an MMA career.

Positives: Adequate height for the position. Above-average hand size. Runs with above-average speed and quickness, with good burst through the line. Has quick feet and above-average ability to stop his momentum and get back to speed with good acceleration. Is a sudden runner who seems to be fearless – hits the hole hard and decisively. Is also a creative runner who has very good vision for cutback lanes but also keeps squared while he makes moves, allowing him to change directions with good balance and consistently move forward. Fairly patient and will set up and follow his blockers well. Above-average power and is willing and able to lower his shoulders and churn his legs after contact to drive through defenders for extra yards. Breaks through arm tackles easily. Runs with good body lean and shows good balance after contact. Is also agile and has a nice spin move. He really seems to get everything possible out of every run. Changes hands well in the open field. Adequate hands. Willing and adequate downfield blocker. Seems to have strong hands.

Negatives: Had several incidents at the Combine and in the weeks following, leading to his walking away from football. Left the combine early for religious reasons. Missed his pro day and was fired by his agent. As of May, 2014, he is reportedly seeing an MMA career. Below-average bulk for the position. Suspect pass blocker and probably needs more experience at it. Needs better ball security technique through the line. Injured his ankle early in the 2013 season and it affected his quickness throughout the season. Projection: Not even worth a late-round flier in dynasty rookie drafts at this point.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Zach Mettenberger, QB, LSU

Titans, Round 6. He showed some skills as a passer in college, but his lack of mobility – which may be even worse after his knee injury – will probably keep him from being consistently successful in the NFL. After his injury, he began throwing again in early February 2014. He won’t be ready for any off-season activities, and may not even be ready for the 2014 NFL season, but this will give him a chance to sit on the Titans bench and learn the game.

All-Star Games: None.Invited to the Senior Bowl but declined due to injury.

Positives: great height and good bulk for the position. Above-average hand size. Has experience running a pro-style offense, so he should be fairly ready to run an NFL offense. Adequate arm strength and throws with good velocity. Can vary his release point and throw with touch when needed. Is able to throw with above-average accuracy and touch on intermediate passes when he has a clean pocket to throw in. Seems tough, and doesn’t get rattled under pressure. Though he is nowhere near mobile, he is able to step up in the pocket under outside rush. Knows when to throw the ball away.

Negatives: Inconsistent accuracy, and below average when he is on the move or otherwise unable to set his feet. Lacks mobility, and doesn’t move well inside the pocket. Below-average speed. Below-average ball security when in pocket. Often looks to check down to short and medium passes. Fairly indecisive. Tends to overthrow on the run. Doesn’t sense pocket collapsing. Tore left ACL in November 2013, missed the rest of the season, and had surgery in January 2014, but worked out at April pro day. Incident at bar in 2010 and was released from Georgia and then transferred to LSU. Gave a diluted urine sample for his Combine drug test.

Projection: He is not worth drafting in fantasy rookie drafts, but keep an eye on him next year to see how he improves with more NFL coaching. I see a Ryan Lindley-like NFL career ahead of him – and I was a fan of Lindley.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Aaron Murray, QB, Georgia

Chiefs, Round 5. On the Chiefs, he should be a solid backup to Alex Smith with the potential to be a solid starter if need be. He needs to clean up his mechanics and improve his reading of defenses a bit, but he has the skills to be a solid backup in the NFL.

All-Star Games: None. Was invited to the Senior Bowl but declined due to injury.

Positives: Though his height and bulk are below average, he is built solidly. Adequate hand size. Has experience running a pro-style offense, so he should be more ready to run an NFL offense.Throws with adequate arm strength and velocity. Shows good accuracy and touch on intermediate passes. Above-average deep accuracy, especially on deep out patterns. Recognizes and exploits single coverage well on the outside. Runs with above-average speed and quickness. Fair pocket presence, and can step up in the pocket under outside pressure.

Negatives: Below-average height and bulk for the position. Seems to have some trouble reading defenses over the middle of the field – especially the deep safety – and will throw passes into coverage. Tends to hold the ball too long and needs to learn when to just throw it away. Though he was able to hit the deep pass well in college, he will need to throw with a steeper trajectory in the pros to keep deep passes away from defenders. Doesn’t throw with much touch, and will often throw it too hard for receivers to catch. Not consistently effective passing on the run, and will often throw into coverage. Below-average throwing mechanics when he is on the run, and he doesn’t set feet to pass, resulting in passes that die and negatively impacting his accuracy. Also seems to have some trouble throwing passes to running backs in the flat. Tends to tighten up in the pocket, throwing off his throwing motion. Tore left ACL in November 2013 and had surgery, missing the rest of the season, returning to throw at his April pro day.

Projection: There is probably no reason to draft him in fantasy rookie drafts, but keep an eye on him in the preseason to see how he improves with NFL coaching.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

AJ McCarron, QB, Alabama

Bengals, Round 5. I expected him to go in Round 2, and thought he had third-round skills, but he went a lot later than I, and probably he, expected. On the Bengals, he’ll make a solid backup to Andy Dalton and could develop into a solid backup for years to come. Probably wouldn’t even hurt many teams starting for them.

All-Star Games: None. Was invited to the Senior Bowl, but declined.

Positives: Good height and above-average bulk for the position. Above-average hand size. Has experience running a pro-style offense. Throws with adequate arm strength and velocity. Okay velocity. Throws with nice touch and accuracy on intermediate throws and shows above-average anticipation on timing routes, hitting receivers as they come out of their breaks. Above-average deep accuracy. Shows some patience, and goes through his progressions around half the time. As a result, he spreads the ball around fairly well. Is effective throwing back-shoulder passes. Outside of the pocket, he shows good accuracy and patience, and knows when to just throw ball away. Tough – played with dislocated ribs for second half of 2012. Was also the holder on field goals.

Negatives: Below-average track speed, explosiveness, change of direction ability, and lateral quickness. Indecisive and holds the ball too long at times – even when a checkdown is obviously available. Release point varies from three-quarter to sidearm at times. Eyeballs receivers fairly often. Doesn’t consistently read deep safety on long passes, resulting in long interceptions. His field of vision narrows considerably when he’s on the run, and he won’t see open receivers. Even in the pocket, he will miss better reads over the middle. Looks uncomfortable moving around in pocket. He doesn’t sense outside rushers very well and needs to learn when to step up in the pocket under outside pressure. Below-average ball security on the run, and runs with the ball away from his body in one hand. There are some questions about his dedication since he has decided to forego both the Senior Bowl and potentially even the Combine.

Projection: He’s not draftable in dynasty rookie leagues, but feel free to in super-deep leagues. Probably won’t ever be a fantasy factor.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Marqise Lee, WR/PR, USC

Jaguars, Round 2. Was a junior. Went a little lower than I and most others expected, but not by much. And he goes to a team with a growing need for a wide receiver, with Blackmon’s history of – and recent – troubles. If Blackmon returns and keeps his head on straight, they have a very nice, young WR corps for years. But if he doesn’t, Lee will pair with Cecil Shorts and Ace Sanders, and with new QB Blake Bortles, to still give the Jaguars offense a solid beginning. Has the skills to be a solid WR in the NFL, though he has some big durability concerns. Should contribute immediately as a punt returner and as a complementary WR.

Positives: Runs with good speed and acceleration and above-average quickness. Above-average hands and good concentration on difficult catches. Runs good routes, with quick, crisp breaks getting good angles on the ball. Good body control and adjusts well to errant passes. Elusive after the catch. Comes back to the quarterback on scramble drill.Looks like he’s tough enough to play through pain. Adequate hand size. Adequate track speed for his size and position. Above-average vertical leap, lateral quickness, and general lower body explosiveness in Combine testing.

Negatives: Slightly below-average height and bulk for the position. Though his hands are generally above average, he shows lapses in concentration on easy passes where he wants to turn upfield before securing the pass. Tends to dance around too much after the catch. As a kick returner, will go sideways and not necessarily head upfield. Below-average ball security – holds loose and away from body. Seems a little contact shy on passes over the middle. Major durability concerns. Slightly injured his knee before spring practice 2013. Then he injured his knee again in September 2013 and missed two games. Then, he came back and reinjured it, but came back again the next week. Doesn’t look too comfortable tracking passes over his shoulder.

Projection: If the team’s offense improves, he has the skills to eventually put up WR1 numbers in fantasy, but only expect WR3 numbers for a while. Feel free to use a late-first-round pick in your dynasty rookie league drafts.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Mike Evans, WR, Texas A&M

Buccaneers, Round 1. Was a redshirt sophomore.

Positives: Great height and bulk for the position – H-back size. Above-average hand size. Great wingspan. Very physical wide receiver with good hands. Tracks passes over his inside shoulder very well. Runs above-average routes and uses his physicality well for positioning and boxing out defenders. Comes back to help quarterback when scrambling. Has strong hands and an overall strong body. Shows good body control and adjusts well to off-target passes. Should be very effective and difficult to cover in the red zone. Adequate track speed for the position, but above-average for his size. Above-average vertical leap.

Negatives: Hands aren’t great in wet conditions, and he will also let some passes get to his body. Doesn’t get much separation on his routes, and puts himself in a position where he has to outmuscle defenders instead of making a clean catch. Seems to be a bit of a hothead when a play doesn’t go his way. Below-average upper body strength. Below-average lateral quickness and ability to change directions in Combine testing.

Projection: In one of the most obvious matches in the draft, he went to the Buccaneers at pick 7 to pair with his clone, Vincent Jackson. Is also very similar to Alshon Jeffery, the Bears WR, with his size, physicality, hands, lack of separation skills – and his personality. His drafting by the Bucs gives them a pair of WRs a whole lot like the Bears duo of Jeffery and Marshall, and I expect Evans to have a similar level of success in a similar amount of time. He also becomes an obvious replacement for Jackson when he’s gone, since Jackson’s already 31. Draft as an immediate WR2 with WR1 upside.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Sammy Watkins, WR/KR, Clemson

Bills, Round 1. 

Positives: adequate height for the position and above-average bulk. Above-average hand size. Above-average speed. Accelerates well off the line and after the catch and has quick feet off the line to get away from press coverage. Excellent hands, and extends well and consistently. Highpoints passes well, and makes difficult catches seem easy. Can catch passes even when defender hits him at the same time. Tracks deep passes well over his inside shoulder. Above-average routes and is quick in and out of his breaks. Good vertical leap and will win jump-ball situations. Creative, with good vision in the open field to find yards after the catch. Above-average balance after contact. Patient runner after the catch and is very effective getting yards after the catch. Decisive in the open field and will get upfield quickly after receptions and on returns. Very willing to be physical and throw body around, and usually fights hard for extra yards. Pretty good kick-return decisions. Very experienced at wide-receiver screen plays. Above-average upper body strength.

Negatives: Not a great route runner – seems to telegraph when he’s making a cut. Though he fights for yards, he isn’t strong enough to break tackles for more yards after contact. And though he usually seemed tough in college, he seemed leery of contact in Clemson’s 2014 bowl game and was too willing to duck out of bounds instead of lowering his shoulder for more yards. Was he worried about the draft? Below-average vertical leap, lateral quickness, and ability to change directions in Combine testing, though that all seems like an aberration from his game tape. Also shows suspect ball-security technique. Drug arrest in 2012.

Projection: Before the draft, I projected him to go in the first eight picks, so I’m not surprised he went at number four. He has a lot of elite receiving skills and was consistently and excellently productive in college. He joins a WR corps in Buffalo that’s improving – with Robert Woods, Mike Williams, Steve Johnson, and Marquise Goodwin – and only gets a lot better with the addition of Watkins. However, he does come with questions about his character and how Clemson’s passing game translates to the NFL. He should be a solid immediate starter, regardless, and he could start at any wide-receiver position on the Bills. He’d be especially effective out of the slot, where he can more easily get the ball away from coverage to let him run free. He had added a huge playmaking component to an offense that needed it, and, in dynasty rookie drafts, he’s worth a top-two pick as an immediate WR2 with WR1 potential by year two.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Lache Seastrunk, RB, Baylor

Redskins, Round 6. Was a redshirt junior and former transfer from Oregon. Went much later than I expected, which was Round 3. Released by Washington, DC, team in August. May be the best of the smaller backs in this draft and he should become a pretty good contributor on some team. Needs to work on his pass blocking if he is to become an effective third-down back in the NFL, though. Until then, he won’t see much action, I think. Should eventually be a solid change-of-pace back in a committee approach.

Positives: Though his height and weight are slightly below-average, he has a solid build. Adequate hand size. Runs with above-average speed and good burst. Is very agile and has quick feet per sudden changes in direction. Very good vision behind the line and in the open field. Patient and makes his way through the line appearing almost leisurely. Very effective on outside runs, where he can use his quickness to make individual defenders miss. Good balance after contact and when making cuts. Very nimble on the sidelines, and can tiptoe the line and then cut it back inside. Good effort. Great vertical leap.

Negatives: Slightly below-average height and bulk for the position. Below-average upper body strength for the position. After contact, he tends to lean in rather than churn his legs to break through. Though he is very effective on outside runs, he has a harder time on runs up the middle. Looks like he will freelance at times and not follow his blockers. Sometimes appears hesitant. Below-average pass blocker – doesn’t meet defenders far up enough away from the quarterback and he tends to lower his head before impact, get stood up by defenders and bowled over. Injured groin in November 2013 and missed some time, but played in bowl game.

Projection: Even though he’s been released, he’s still definitely worth holding onto in dynasty leagues because he’ll make another team and contribute.

Posted in Fantasy Football, football | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment